Sunday, June 29, 2008

Brazilian Waxing Brooksville

Who governs fear? We

Alessandro Dal Lago
by Liberation - June 27, 2008

The idea of \u200b\u200bbiopolitics, coined by Michel Foucault in some courses at the Collège de France in the late seventies, means today, in the philosophical and political debate, the various areas where the government is exercised in life, or the definition and practice of living as a constant subject of public controversy: the conflict on the personality of the embryo to birth control and sexual ethics migration.

In fact, the most powerful actor in the field of biopolitics is now the Catholic Church, which exercises, legitimately or not, the claim to rule in each field expressions of life. But, in general, "as live" (and of course how to die) is at stake in the conflict between left and right, secular and Catholic and so on. From values \u200b\u200bto be passed on to our children in campaigns against alcoholism youth, bullying, soft drugs and so on, until the "good death", the conduct of political life is a battleground, and then of "governmentality." This does not mean that he is being reborn as something the state ethics (though the Church and the fundamentalist right, in all over the world have surely head in something like that), but that the 'ethics' (and hence the individual conduct) tends to replace the great themes of the twentieth century: the public welfare, social justice, political freedom and so on.

One aspect of biopolitics, in a broad sense, which I think is important today is what I would describe as Daseinpolitik, or 'political existence' or sein. Numerous signs suggest that aspects of the human condition that, in the philosophy of the twentieth century, were the sole responsibility of the individual subject (based on the classic, Being and Time by Martin Heidegger) are subject to investment policy. As usual, not we are talking about a plot or big brothers but a trend, both culturally and politically divided and pervasive. Consider, for example, the ubiquitous question of 'insecurity'. Today, this has nothing to do with "ontological insecurity" was talking about forty years ago in the anti-psychiatrist Ronald Laing 'I split, and that is the sense of existential inconsistency or uncertainty that sooner or later take anyone, more or less bearable. Instead, insecurity is a matter strictly social and concrete. "When I walk down the street I'm not feeling safe," "The crimes are more or less stable but growing insecurity of the people," "Illegal immigration produces insecurity "here is typical expressions that every day we read in newspapers and on which the political class is expressed tirelessly. It then became in every point of view policies.

that security - and thus the reduction of insecurity - is a primary goal of any good government has been known since the time of the chamber. Indeed, the foundation of the modern state, what is called Westphalian and corresponds more or less the definition of the state as Weberian "monopoly of legitimate violence." As you know, safety at stake in the classical political theories about life in the narrow sense: in the famous allegory of the Hobbesian Leviathan, citizens delegate to the prince any use of weapons to be protected, and nell'incolumità in assets, from murderers, adverse and hostile religious factions. Hobbes was particularly sensitive to this issue. Early in his autobiography in verse, Vita carmine express, he recalls that his premature birth was caused by the panic that spread to England, on arrival dell'Invencible Armada: "And It Was Hereupon my dear mother / Did bring forth twins at once, Both me and fear "(" And so my dear mother gave birth to twins at a time, and I fear). In the last verse, Hobbes says that only now, at the end of his life when he did what he thought was right and only death awaits, "is no longer afraid."

Protection of life and property is therefore the least that a state must offer to individuals. Of course, this primary raison d'etre of public facilities has declined in very different ways depending on the political culture. In the U.S., where substantially all the citizens have the right to use arms to defend their homes from intruders, the lack of a national health system makes a negligible share of the population does not enjoy a real health protection. But in any case it is clear that a state is structurally incapable of functioning in this sense see erode the very foundations of its legitimacy.

Apparently, the above is exactly in the sense of the rhetoric of public safety che ho evocato sopra come un aspetto della «politica dell'esistenza». Qualcuno che magari conosce le mie precedenti opinioni in materia penserà che mi sono convertito, che so, alla filosofia politica - se vogliamo chiamarla così - di Maroni o Veltroni (le cui idee in tema di sicurezza sono molto simili). Ma è esattamente il contrario: io ritengo che proprio l'incessante retorica pubblica dell'insicurezza dilagante non abbia a che fare con la sicurezza dei cittadini, ma con il loro governo, e cioè con la loro subordinazione. Che apparentemente i cittadini approvino tale retorica, stando ai sondaggi, non mi sorprende più di tanto. E non solo per quel fenomeno che l'amico di Montaigne, Etiene de La Boetie, cinque secoli fa, chiamava suggestively "voluntary servitude." How much and especially because it is very difficult for a rhetoric produced today by the entire political class (with very slight differences in emphasis between the government and opposition) does not enjoy favor for a while, because daily diet. Of course, no historical cycle is eternal: there is no reason that sooner or later public opinion does not decide to ask its leaders to account for what they say, with a simple question worthy of Andersen's tale, the emperor's clothes: "But if we speak of fifteen years of insecurity, not by any chance you have never been able to do something about it? ". God have mercy on those government when the voters discover that they have been deceived for so long.

The truth is that the rulers will never do anything, given the fantastic premise dell'incessante rhetoric. To put it succinctly, no one can ever heal the pain of insecurity: in 1992 in Italy should kill 1,200 people each year, and now little more than half, does not tell us anything about the real chance of being killed in the past sixteen years. And the same goes for that of being mugged, robbed, and so on. The statistics are a summary only numerical outcome of random processes and largely unpredictable, not literally mean nothing to our lives. I, for example, I lived for several months in a city, Los Angeles, whose county is home to 14 million inhabitants and is marred by 1,000 murders a year - in due proportion, as if in Italy there are 5,000 murders, that is nine times the actual number, a figure that someone would ask of the curfew. Well, according to Los Angeles, I perceived no risk, no attempt on my life and I even forgot a couple of times to close the door. It 's true that I lived in a neighborhood considered safe (but many of my acquaintances said they were generally afraid ...). In short, as the reduction in street crime does not protect us from the possibility of a theft, so the percentage of murders on a number people will not let us be sure that tomorrow there aggredirà someone with a knife. In these areas, insecurity is a matter of points of view, character, and of course if suggestibility.

So in all respects corresponds to the enigmatic nature of existence. That's why I called Daseinpolitik, "political existence", that kind of public rhetoric that relies sull'umanissima existential fear and uncertainty to justify itself, and thus the government. To give an idea of \u200b\u200bwhat I intend to offer just one example, which is obviously of no value, if not metaphorical. They ask me to sign a petition against the owners of a bar doorstep that is open until late at night ed è perciò causa di un frastuono intollerabile. Non amo il genere «cittadini che non ne possono più,» ma sono disposto a considerare la cosa, finché non leggo che la petizione è diretta all'assessore comunale alla sicurezza. Ma che c'entra la sicurezza? Qui è questione di regolamenti comunali in tema di pubblici esercizi, e quindi la petizione o protesta dovrebbe essere indirizzata ai carabinieri o alla polizia municipale. Ma non capisce che qui è in gioco il degrado della città? Mi si risponde. No, non capisco. La verità pura e semplice è che dopo l'incessante campagna sulla sicurezza, risolvere il problema del frastuono è possibile solo con l'equazione: «Frastuono uguale degrado uguale insicurezza equal to (implicitly) immigration. " The result is ultimately responsible for the noise will not be considered operators of the bar (and the limit that the municipal authorities do nothing), but the Moroccan boys dangling at night with beer in hand.

Insecurity has such broad contours of which can cover everything and do not correspond to anything in particular. Or rather is something that is taken for granted as a necessity and you do not even dream of interpreting. It 's true, the trend of crimes, mostly in decline, does not explain the feeling of insecurity, but if people have this perception, we must do something ... that's what he says one day and go off any editorial national newspapers, large and small. I find that intellectually repugnant rhetoric. Firstly, because this type of message, it is pounding, it ends up food and increase their sense of insecurity and uncertain contours unknowable (but journalists never think that television and newspapers are in the public eye, the reality?) And then it ends up in justifying any shame, which would turn over in his grave I will not say Capitini Aldo, but even the old Beccaria. Here are some examples and an empirical case.

a month about the Roma are expelled from all the settlements do not know where. For some time the prefects of the big cities are also filing Sinti, mostly Italian citizenship, sending the police at dawn in their settlements, as if they were criminals. In any civil place, this would be considered discrimination based on ethnicity (the citizens are cataloged according to their supposed origin) and therefore inadmissible. Perfectly right to protest a Sinti well-known survivor of a family exterminated by the Nazis, the reporter of a popular daily newspaper (not to mention just a glimmer of love) objects more or less: "But they do it for you, to determine who is performs well and who's not .... " In short, if you wake up at five in the morning for boards and terrorize your kids, do it for your own good. Note not only the hypocrisy of the argument, but implicitly siding with the authorities of the journalist. What is there to make the Order of the journalists if they do not teach its members that the task of a true journalist is to describe and explain what happens to the limit, and do not do morality (and moral!) To victims of an injustice?

empirical case: the small wave of pogroms against Roma in Naples would have been caused by the alleged attempted rape of a child by a nomad. Immediately the Opera and other nomadic groups have pointed out that there is only one recorded case or tried in the war of children abducted by the Roma (in exchange know at least three similar hoaxes in recent years, which were deflated in just a few days). The investigation is ongoing and scommetto la mia reputazione che si è trattato, nel caso peggiore, di un equivoco. Ma tutta la stampa nazionale ha riportato l'episodio prendendolo per buono: «Nomade rapisce un bambino a Napoli, eccetera» Mi sarebbe piaciuta una controinchiesta, tenuto anche conto che da quelle parti opera la camorra, che non va tanto per il sottile quando si tratta di deviare l'attenzione pubblica dai propri misfatti. Ma credo che l'aspetterò per molto tempo. Ed ecco che cos'è l'insicurezza, almeno nell'Italia d'oggi: un misto di balle mediali, cinismo politico e anche, perché no, panico generalizzato.
Pensare che in queste condizioni i sondaggi sulla percezione dell'insicurezza o dell'immigrazione - propinati instancabilmente by the media - they are true is to have an idea of \u200b\u200bthe curious truth: it is true what the media offer as such. Walter Lippman, who was not really an anarchist, quipped about this claim at least sixty years ago. With

policy not mean the existence of a plot or a plan to subject, but a handy way to distract us from the reality of a country incattivito, no sense of the future, where wages are lower than elsewhere, the universities in agony, young people without hope of stable employment and garbage overflowing from the bins. By creating a ubiquitous enemy, indefinable and fungible (Moroccan, Roma, Albanians, rapists on the street corner, pedophiles in the gardens), the real flaws in to sink is minimized and the political class can continue doing the good life. And the papers to sell their alarmism. Poor Hobbes. At least his mother was afraid of the formidable English army.

Pictures Kazz [ Fear Box 2 - The Revenge ] Creative Commons license from Flickr

0 comments:

Post a Comment